Ask most women which shoe they wear most and the answer is a black flat. It goes with every trouser, every skirt and every coat; it passes at work and at dinner; it hides a scuff and a rainy day. This collection gathers every women's shoe we make that comes in black: black loafers, black ballet flats, black Mary Janes and black driving shoes, in leather, suede, patent and woven finishes.
How to choose a black flat
Start with the shape, because in black the shape is all anyone sees. A black loafer is the office pair and the most versatile shoe in the collection; a plain leather one with a round toe goes with everything. A black ballet flat is lighter and softer, and in a pointed toe it replaces a court shoe. A black Mary Jane adds a strap and a buckle and stays on all day. A black chunky loafer gives height and weight for winter. Then choose the finish: smooth leather for work, suede for a softer look, patent for evenings and rain, woven for summer. Each product page states the upper, the lining and the sole.
Why black, honestly
Black flats look the same after a hundred wears as after ten. Scuffs polish out, marks do not show, and a black shoe with a black sock and a black trouser makes a leg look longer than any other combination. It is also the colour where quality shows most, because there is nothing else to look at: the shape of the toe, the line of the top edge, the finish of the sole. That is why we keep the black pairs plain.
Fit
Fit follows the shape, not the colour. Loafers and round toe flats fit true to size; pointed toes run snugger across the toes, so take the half size up if you are between sizes on a pointed shape; suede gives more than leather; chunky soles give less. The size guide gives the inside length of every size in centimetres so you can compare against a pair you already wear. Exchanges within the UK are free and returns are accepted within 30 days.
How to wear them
Black loafer, black trouser, white shirt: the uniform. Black pointed flat, grey trouser, black knit: dinner after work. Black Mary Jane, midi skirt, fine black sock: autumn. Black patent flat, slip dress: a wedding. Black chunky loafer, wide jean, long coat: winter. There is no outfit in a wardrobe a black flat does not finish.
Three black flats, three days
Monday: a black leather loafer, a navy trouser, a striped shirt. Wednesday evening: a black patent pointed flat, black wide trousers, a silk top, gold earrings. Saturday: a black suede Mary Jane, a grey midi skirt, a fine black sock, a camel coat. The same colour three times, and three different shoes, because in black it is the shape and the finish that do the talking. That is why the black pair is worth choosing carefully and why most customers own more than one.
Care
Black is the easiest colour to keep. A black cream every fortnight on leather fills scuffs and keeps the shine. A suede brush and a protector spray on suede. A damp cloth on patent. Let wet pairs dry naturally with paper inside. Rotate two pairs; a day off lets the insole dry and the upper recover.
Building a black rotation
Two black flats cover a working week: a leather loafer and a pointed flat. Three cover a year, with a Mary Jane for skirts and weddings. Four add a chunky loafer for winter. Rotating them is not a luxury; a shoe worn every day never dries fully and wears out in half the time, while two pairs alternated last far longer than twice as long. Buy the loafer first, and the rest as the seasons ask for them.
Black in summer
A black flat is not only a winter shoe. In a woven or a mesh, it keeps an office look through a heatwave; in a jelly, it is the rainy-day pair; in patent, it is the evening pair with a slip dress. A black pointed flat with white jeans is a sharp summer outfit. What changes with the season is the material, not the colour, and this collection has a black pair in every material we make.
Before you order
Decide the shape first, then the finish. Check the product page for the upper, because black leather, black suede and black patent behave differently in rain and in fit. Size by the shape as usual: true to size for loafers and round toes, the half size up for pointed toes.
Delivery and returns
Free tracked delivery on every UK order. Returns within 30 days of delivery, free UK exchanges, and a real person at contact@asterfordshoes.com Monday to Friday.
Frequently asked questions
Which black flat first? A plain black leather loafer with a round toe. It is the shoe that does the most.
Leather or suede in black? Leather for work and rain, suede for a softer evening look. Black suede shows less than pale suede and is a good first suede.
Do black flats fade? Leather and patent, no. Suede can lighten slightly with wear; a black suede spray restores it.
Are black flats smart enough for a wedding? A pointed toe in patent or a Mary Jane with a buckle, yes. A plain round toe reads as everyday.